Unraveling the Mystery of the Circleville Letters
Written on
Chapter 1: The Start of the Nightmare
In the serene town of Circleville, Ohio, an ominous figure emerged from the shadows to torment Mary Gillispie, an elementary school bus driver. The first unsettling letter appeared in her mailbox during the summer of 1976. This anonymous correspondent warned Gillispie about her purported affair with Gordon Massie, the superintendent of the Westfall School District. The letter ominously stated, “I know where you live. I’ve been watching your home and know you have children. This is no joke. Please take it seriously.”
The chilling tone of the letter left Gillispie rattled, yet she chose not to confront the threats head-on.
Section 1.1: Escalating Threats
When Mary dismissed the initial threats, the writer escalated their campaign by sending letters addressed to her husband, Ron. The correspondence warned him that he needed to confront his wife about the alleged affair or face deadly consequences. Mary reassured Ron that the accusations were unfounded, prompting them to delay reporting the matter to authorities in hopes that the harassment would cease. However, the tormentor was just getting warmed up. Within weeks, new letters emerged, threatening to expose the supposed affair on CB radio and billboards.
As the situation intensified, Ron and Mary confided in family members, starting with Ron's sister, Karen, and her husband, Paul Freshour. During these discussions, Mary suggested that David Longberry, a fellow bus driver who had previously expressed interest in her, might be the culprit. The family decided to take action by having Paul write to Longberry, demanding the harassment stop.
Subsection 1.1.1: The Calm Before the Storm
For a short time, the letters ceased. However, new signs appeared around town, suggesting an even more disturbing trend: claims that Gordon Massie was romantically involved with the Gillispie’s 12-year-old daughter, Traci.
In August 1977, Ron received a threatening phone call that made him believe he was being watched. Armed and determined, he left his home, convinced he was about to confront the tormentor.
Section 1.2: Tragedy Strikes
Ron’s resolve led him to an unfortunate fate. His truck veered off the road and collided with a tree, resulting in his death. Although the coroner ruled it an accident, many—including his brother-in-law Paul—suspected foul play. Despite Ron’s death, the letters targeting Mary and Gordon continued unabated.
Years passed, and in 1983, Mary stumbled upon a trap meant for her daughter. While removing a sign along her bus route, she discovered a box containing a loaded gun. This pivotal find linked back to the Circleville Letters and directed investigators to their prime suspect—Paul Freshour.
The first video titled "The Chilling Mystery Of The Circleville Letters" explores the eerie origins of the letters and the implications they had on the Gillispie family.
Chapter 2: Unraveling Suspicions
Confronted with evidence, Freshour's wife, Karen Sue, made a shocking confession to police, claiming Freshour was behind the letters. However, despite evidence and a failed polygraph test, he maintained his innocence. During the trial, handwriting specialists suggested he could be the author of the letters, leading to his conviction for attempted murder in 1984.
Yet, the story didn’t end there. After his imprisonment, the letters resurfaced, reaching hundreds of residents, including Freshour himself. One letter taunted him, stating, “Now, when are you going to believe you aren’t getting out of there? I told you two years ago: When we set ’em up, they stay set up. Don’t you listen at all?”
The second video titled "The Chilling Case of the CIRCLEVILLE LETTER WRITER - UNSOLVED?" delves deeper into the unsolved aspects of this haunting case and its lasting impact on the community.
With the re-emergence of the Circleville Letters, police once again shifted their focus, this time towards Karen Sue and her boyfriend, who bore a striking resemblance to a witness description from the booby trap incident.
Years passed without any new leads until December 1993, when "Unsolved Mysteries" aired an episode on the case. Shortly after, Freshour was released from prison on parole, coinciding with the cessation of the letters.
Until his death in June 2012, Freshour continued to assert his innocence. Today, nearly five decades later, the mystery surrounding the Circleville Letters persists. If not Freshour, then who could be the true author?