panhandlefamily.com

Exploring the Efficacy of Surveillance in Combating Coronavirus

Written on

The State of Surveillance

In today's world, the Coronavirus looms large in public consciousness, and for good reason. As of March 4, the virus has confirmed cases in over 70 countries, totaling more than 90,000 worldwide. Lawmakers are grappling with difficult choices in their attempts to manage this pandemic. Recent updates from the World Health Organization (WHO) indicate that while uncertainty persists, effective containment is achievable — though not without significant costs.

WHO Director-General Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus noted promising trends in China, stating, “We are in unchartered territory,” but emphasized that “containment of COVID-19 is feasible and must remain the top priority for all countries.” China, which still accounts for a substantial portion of global cases, has been lauded as a model for controlling the virus. The government's rapid response to quarantine cities and deploy surveillance technologies has played a pivotal role in controlling the outbreak.

How is China using surveillance to fight coronavirus? - BBC News

This video delves into the strategies employed by the Chinese government, including the use of drones and facial recognition technology to monitor the population. It raises questions about privacy and the extent of governmental oversight during health crises.

The Cost of Containment

Before discussing the merits and drawbacks of China's surveillance tactics, it is essential to understand the stakes involved. The WHO estimates the Coronavirus has a mortality rate of approximately 3.4%, significantly higher than that of seasonal flu and only slightly lower than the 1918 Spanish Flu. Unlike recent high-profile outbreaks like Ebola and Zika, the Coronavirus can manifest with mild or no symptoms, making it difficult for those infected to seek medical care, thereby facilitating its spread.

In a recent piece for The Atlantic, Harvard epidemiologist Marc Lipsitch projected that between 40% and 70% of the global population could contract the virus within a year. With the stated mortality rate, this could result in a staggering death toll, potentially exceeding 99 million, which would far surpass the 1918 outbreak.

However, these projections are steeped in uncertainty regarding the virus's spread, vaccine effectiveness, and public response. Lipsitch cautioned that while many infections may be mild or asymptomatic, the potential impact remains alarming.

The Role of Surveillance

Given these daunting statistics, the global response has been swift, with some nations resorting to "radical tactics" to avert a catastrophic health crisis. Surveillance has emerged as a central strategy in these efforts.

While reports have highlighted China's initial failure to recognize the outbreak, the government quickly reversed course, enforcing strict measures. The city of Wuhan was effectively sealed off, isolating around 11 million residents, a move made possible by the extensive surveillance infrastructure developed over decades.

Drones equipped with facial recognition capabilities are now monitoring compliance with mask mandates, while infrared scanners check for fever at transportation hubs. Additionally, robots are deployed to remind citizens to remain indoors. Reports indicate that the government has even encouraged residents to report on one another, reminiscent of tactics used in North Korea.

As restrictions begin to ease, new surveillance measures are being implemented. Workers returning to their jobs must use a mobile tracking app that assigns color codes (green, yellow, or red) to indicate their health status, determining their ability to leave quarantine or access public spaces.

COVID 19 Surveillance Testing: A Way Out? | Daniel Larremore

This video examines the implications of surveillance testing in managing the pandemic and discusses the balance between public health and individual privacy.

Implications for Privacy and Governance

While the introduction of such an app might seem justifiable in the face of a pandemic, it raises critical questions about privacy and state power. Analysis of the app's code revealed that it could share personal information with law enforcement, a connection that users may not fully understand.

Moreover, the Chinese government has enacted new laws restricting the dissemination of negative information online, ostensibly to promote a positive digital environment and safeguard national security. This legislation underscores a troubling trend of increased governmental control over public discourse, particularly during a health crisis.

Despite its initial shortcomings, the Chinese government's aggressive tactics have garnered praise from organizations like the WHO for their effectiveness in curbing the virus's spread. However, the centralized authority of the Chinese Communist Party allows for swift decision-making, often at the expense of public debate and accountability.

Conclusion: A Balancing Act

In times of crisis, the balance between security and civil liberties becomes paramount. The post-9/11 era in the United States serves as a reminder of how fear can drive the public to accept invasive surveillance measures. While the urgency of preventing a pandemic justifies certain actions, the long-term consequences of such measures must be carefully considered.

The Chinese government's approach serves as a stark example of how surveillance can expand under the guise of public safety, presenting a cautionary tale for governments worldwide. Ultimately, as we navigate these challenging times, it is crucial to weigh the sacrifices we are willing to make in the name of security against the values we hold dear.

If you enjoyed this analysis, consider subscribing to my bi-weekly newsletter, The State of Surveillance, for ongoing insights into surveillance technology and its implications.

The State of Surveillance

Stay informed about the latest trends in surveillance technology and its global impact.

mack.substack.com

Share the page:

Twitter Facebook Reddit LinkIn

-----------------------

Recent Post:

Navigating the Signs of a Misaligned Relationship

Discover five indicators that suggest you might be in a relationship that isn’t right for you, helping you to find a path to healthier connections.

Rediscovering the Self: Embracing the Second Half of Life

A personal journey of rediscovery and healing in the second half of life, inspired by Richard Rohr's insights.

The Rise of Mammals: From Dinosaurs to Dominance in Earth’s History

Explore the transition from dinosaurs to mammals in Earth's history, detailing the evolution and rise of mammals after the Cretaceous.

Writing Guidance That's Actually Helpful: Achieving Success as a Writer

Discover practical writing advice for aspiring authors aiming for success without the usual gimmicks.

Embracing Life Beyond Hustle Culture: A Call for Balance

Explore the pitfalls of hustle culture and the importance of living fully before retirement.

Embracing Solo Travel as a Married Woman: A Journey to Independence

Exploring the joys of solo travel as a married woman and how it can strengthen relationships.

The Unsung Mathematical Genius of Thomas Fuller: A Legacy Forgotten

Discover the extraordinary life of Thomas Fuller, a slave with unmatched mental calculation skills, and his impact on perceptions of race and intelligence.

Understand Men: 9 Essential Guidelines for Relationship Harmony

Discover nine crucial principles to enhance your relationship with men, ensuring mutual understanding and harmony.