The Surprising Origins of Red Food Dye: Insects and Coal
Written on
Chapter 1: Uncovering Red Food Dye
Have you ever pondered the origins of your favorite red foods? Surprising as it may be, many items we consume contain various color additives. Marshmallows, for instance, may appear white, but they often contain blue dye to maintain their brightness. Starbucks utilizes food coloring in their strawberry beverages, and even frozen seafood, like fish and crab, is tinted red for aesthetic appeal.
But where does this red dye come from? For many varieties, it is derived from an unexpected source: the Cochineal insect, native to Central and South America.
In this exploration, we will delve into the history of using crushed insects for food coloring, identify the foods that may contain this dye, and consider whether we can avoid it—or if the alternatives are even less desirable.
Carmine Red: The Aztec Discovery
The Cochineal insect, a scale insect that feeds on cacti, has a fascinating biology. It creates tiny holes in the cactus to extract moisture and nutrients. To deter predators, the Cochineal produces a bitter-tasting substance known as carminic acid, which comprises a significant portion of the insect's dry weight—between 17% and 24%.
When harvested, these insects are crushed and treated with an acidic solution to extract carminic acid. Through further processing and mixing with salts, this results in carmine dye, a striking red pigment also recognized as Cochineal extract, Natural Red 4, E120, or Crimson Lake. Remarkably, it takes approximately 70,000 Cochineal insects to yield just one pound of Carmine Red dye.
Historically, the Aztecs harvested these insects for their vibrant dye, and after the Spanish conquest, the secret of Carmine Red was kept hidden for over two centuries. It wasn't until the late 1700s that a Frenchman managed to infiltrate a Cochineal plantation and expose its source.
Despite the rise of synthetic dyes in the 1900s, Carmine Red is still widely used in various foods and cosmetics, including eye-catching lipsticks. So, why do we continue to use it despite the availability of synthetic alternatives?
In this video, "The Truth About Red Dye 40: Effects & Myths Explored," we explore the implications of red food dyes and their origins.
Synthetic Alternatives: The Role of Coal
When we think of coal, we often envision its deep black color. However, coal byproducts, as well as petroleum byproducts, can produce various colors, including certain red dyes. Azo dyes, named for their unique chemical structure, are synthetic and were initially derived from coal, later transitioning to petroleum sources.
Two notable synthetic red dyes include amaranth and Allura Red, commonly labeled as Red 2 and Red 40. These dyes are prevalent in many processed foods, from ketchup to candy.
Yet, the consumption of these petroleum-based dyes raises health concerns, particularly regarding cancer risks. For example, amaranth was widely used until the 1970s when studies linked it to potential carcinogenic effects. Although banned in the U.S., it remains permissible in the EU, where regulations require explicit labeling of Red 40.
Interestingly, in the UK, the consumption of certain synthetic food dyes is under scrutiny due to possible connections to hyperactivity in children. Although the evidence is not definitive, caution prevails regarding these artificial additives.
In "Is Red Food Dye Harmful? SHOCKER!! | Ask Dr. David," we discuss the potential health risks associated with synthetic dyes.
Bugs vs. Petroleum: Making the Choice
Ultimately, both types of red food coloring—Carmine Red from Cochineal insects and synthetic dyes like Red 2 and Red 40—carry their own set of potential risks. Carmine can cause allergic reactions and is not suitable for vegans, while synthetic dyes may be linked to cancer and hyperactivity, although these claims often stem from high doses.
After backlash over the use of Carmine Red in their strawberry drinks, Starbucks pledged to switch to a tomato extract-based dye, primarily to cater to vegan customers rather than due to health concerns.
In conclusion, many of us might find it preferable to consume food coloring derived from insects rather than those sourced from petroleum, especially after knowing the story behind it. So the next time you reach for the ketchup, you might have an interesting conversation starter at your next barbecue!