# Methane's Role in Climate Change: Insights from Geological History
Written on
Chapter 1: The Clathrate Gun Hypothesis
Methane, a lightweight, colorless, and odorless gas, plays a significant role in the discourse on global warming. Although human-made sources of methane often dominate climate discussions, the potential risks posed by natural sources remain inadequately understood. Some scientists argue that our geological past contains instances of substantial methane emissions that may have driven climate change.
A basic understanding of how methane is produced, stored, and released in nature is crucial. While human activity contributes significantly to methane emissions, natural processes are also responsible. For example, bacterial decomposition of organic material in low-oxygen settings like wetlands generates over 20% of the Earth's natural methane. Additionally, methane is produced by bacterial action on the ocean floor, commonly referred to as biogenic gas. In total, natural sources account for 52% of global methane emissions, while human activities—especially agriculture and fossil fuel extraction—contribute the remaining share.
One of the most critical aspects of methane regarding climate change is its capacity to trap heat. Over short periods, such as a decade or two, methane can be 87 times more effective than CO2 at warming the atmosphere. However, since methane has a relatively short atmospheric lifespan of about 12 years, its long-term warming potential over a century is approximately 28 times that of CO2.
Thus, the swift release of significant quantities of methane could lead to rapid global temperature increases. Current human activities exemplify the effects of rapidly releasing greenhouse gases, including methane. This leads to the question: Can we identify instances from our geological past where large, rapid methane releases influenced global warming? The answer may lie in the Clathrate Gun Hypothesis.
Chapter 2: Understanding Methane Clathrates
Methane (CH4), commonly known as natural gas, is a vital component of our energy landscape. We utilize it for cooking, heating, and electricity generation. However, vast reserves of methane exist in the form of clathrates, solid structures composed of methane and water, located along deep ocean continental slopes. These formations arise under high pressure and low temperatures typical of deep-sea environments.
As ocean temperatures rise, clathrates can convert back to methane gas and water. The released methane is buoyant, forming gas bubbles that ascend through the water column. While some of this gas may dissolve in seawater, substantial releases can allow methane to reach the ocean surface and escape into the atmosphere. This swift transfer of methane from the seabed to the atmosphere is central to the Clathrate Gun Hypothesis.
The volume of methane trapped in clathrates is immense; the USGS estimates it to be between 4,000 and 200,000 times the total natural gas consumed in the U.S. in 2010. Similar quantities of clathrates likely existed during earlier geological periods when climate conditions mirrored those of today. Warming oceans could trigger the release of this stored methane.
Nonetheless, the occurrence of significant clathrate methane releases in geological history is a topic of considerable debate. Compelling arguments exist on both sides. However, several rapid global warming events have occurred where clathrate methane releases, driven by warming oceans, may have played a significant role. A notable instance of this was during the Eemian period.
Section 2.1: The Eemian Period
The Eemian period, which lasted from approximately 130,000 to 115,000 years ago, represents the last interglacial phase of the Pleistocene. During this time, global temperatures were comparable to today's, with sea levels approximately 20 feet higher.
Research involving ocean sediment cores from the continental slope of West Africa has unearthed two key indicators supporting the Clathrate Gun Hypothesis during the Eemian. Both findings stem from chemical analyses of foraminifera shells, which help infer past ambient temperatures using carbon and oxygen isotopes. These analyses suggest that mid-ocean temperatures increased by over 6 degrees Celsius during the Eemian.
As mid-ocean temperatures rose, the stability of Eemian clathrates was compromised, resulting in substantial methane releases. Additionally, a notable low carbon isotope spike in foraminifera samples from this period suggests an influx of methane into the water due to clathrate breakdown.
Although this evidence does not assert that methane clathrates initiated global temperature increases, it strongly indicates that they may have accelerated the warming process, a scenario that resonates with today's climate challenges.
Section 2.2: The Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum (PETM)
Another geological period of interest regarding methane clathrates is the Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum (PETM). During this event, average global temperatures soared to around 27 degrees Celsius, approximately 13 degrees higher than today's average. The rate of temperature increase leading up to the PETM was rapid from a geological standpoint, yet it remains about 25 times slower than the current rate of anthropogenic warming. Sea levels were roughly 300 feet higher than they are today.
The geological record clearly indicates a substantial rise in atmospheric CO2 during the PETM, accompanied by rapid ocean acidification. An estimated 10 trillion tons of carbon were released into the atmosphere during this event. The reasons behind the increase in atmospheric carbon remain uncertain, but one plausible explanation posits that significant methane releases from ocean-bottom clathrates fueled this brief yet intense period of warming.
The PETM is characterized by a central temperature spike, wherein the planet warmed by 4 degrees Celsius over roughly 20,000 years before experiencing a corresponding decline. A prevailing theory suggests that warming deep ocean waters reached a threshold that destabilized large methane clathrate deposits, causing significant methane emissions into the atmosphere.
This released methane intensified the warming trend, leading to further clathrate breakdown. Eventually, a tipping point was reached where the cycle of warming and methane release became self-perpetuating, continuing until all methane from ocean-floor clathrates was expelled. This massive methane release created conditions that significantly amplified climate warming, resulting in an unusual temperature spike. The brief yet intense temperature rise during the PETM aligns with the behavior of a potent but short-lived greenhouse gas like methane.
Experts remain divided on the current risks posed by seafloor clathrates. However, the considerable volume of methane awaiting release from the ocean depths should prompt careful consideration, especially as global ocean temperatures rise.
Sources:
- Gas Hydrates — Primer (Source: USGS)
- Report of an ancient methane release raises questions for our climate future (Source: The Washington Post)
- Evidence for massive methane hydrate destabilization during the penultimate interglacial warming (Source; PNAS)
This video presents an overview of the Clathrate Gun Hypothesis and its ecological implications, providing further context for understanding methane's role in climate change.